Thursday, June 11, 2009

Page rank, a sterile corporate controlled internet ?

Touching back on a previous post, I highlighted that most new sites I find are via a recommendation from a friend or colleague. Thinking more about this, I was contemplating the last time I actually found a brand new site via a search engine.

The big jump in search engines came when Google went live, toppling the other search engines at the time with its much touted PagRank system returning what was purportedly more relevant search engine results with less spam.

The basic idea being that a trusted authority would be ranked highly, possibly affecting the rank of other sites it has links to. Bing itself uses a enhanced PageRank system.

However what is the cost of the PageRank system? How has it affected the internet and communities involved? It is certain that the PageRank system was a key driving factor in the then emerging SEO (search engine optimisation) industry.

Working regularly with the web optimisation team in my company, which deals with numerous SEO agencies to optimise our web applications I know full well what is entailed in time, effort & cost to ensure a website lists as high as possible in modern search engine rankings.

How is all this relevant?

Simply put, your rank in a PageRank based search engine depends on the amount of time, money & manpower you have available. Further to this, once achieved it is likely that within reason you will be able to maintain your ranking if you continue to invest in a proportional appropriate amount of resources.

Further to this, those sites with a high PageRank are likely to only link to sites within their own corporate domains.

The end result?

Perhaps the end result, is a search ecosystem returning a never ending list of expected results, stagnated by the same system that was intended to return relevancy.

Indexing the entire internet might be a virtuous goal, but to me at least it seems diametrically opposed to the current PageRank based search engines.

No comments:

Post a Comment